Truth Construction

On Forensic Architecture

Forensic Architecture, Chlorine Gas Attacks in Douma, Syria. Reconstruction of the chemical attack site in Douma near to al­-Shuhada square. The discharged chlorine canister, wire mesh fence and deformed harness are visible amongst the wreckage. Courtesy of Forensic Architecture.

Eyal Weizman. Forensic Architecture: Violence at the Threshold of Detectability. Zone Books, 2017.

The video begins with a voice-over delivering grim news. On the fifteenth of May, 2014, Nakba Day, 17-year-old Nadeem Nawara was fatally shot during a protest in the town of Beitunia, near Ramallah. Grainy CCTV footage records a young man as he walks alone beyond the shadow cast by a storefront’s overhang. There’s the sound of a gunshot, and the body crumples. From the perspective of a different camera, people rush to the man’s aid. The video cuts to a third vantage and reprises the last few seconds; again, with the same urgency, several men rush to help the victim, including several journalists wearing bulletproof vests. Dozens of Palestinian teenagers have similarly been killed or wounded by Israeli soldiers and other security personnel in the West Bank in recent years. From local TV news footage there’s a siren, then an ambulance arrives. Most of those killings have taken place off camera and a very small number are investigated. Yet these Nakba Day killings were captured by security cameras installed outside a nearby shop, by television cameras filming the protest (including CNN footage marked warning: disturbing video), as well as by other activists present. A still photograph shows a scrum of more than a dozen young men gathered around the victim, most of them wearing keffiyehs, their faces contorted by desperate cries. Ziem Nawara, his father, found the fatal bullet inside Nadeem’s school bag.

This all unfolds in minute one of a fifteen-minute video that reconstructs the events of that May afternoon. It is a collage of professional, security, and handheld camera footage; still images; sound recordings, including gunshots, and their visualization as waves; and interviews with a variety of experts, including an Israeli ballistics specialist. All of it serves to illustrate the sequence of events, and discover how it happened.

This is the work of Forensic Architecture, a loose association of architects, academics, filmmakers, and artists, based in London, who have combined their skills and tools to investigate the events of May 15, 2014. Was Nadeem Nawara’s death intentional? Who was responsible? What could we learn from the incident about the frequency of deaths at peaceful protests?

More from Issue 32

Issue 32 Bad Faith
The New Reading Environment
Issue 32 Bad Faith

There is no humane border regime, just as there is no humane abortion ban.

Issue 32 Bad Faith
Bad Atrocity Writing
Issue 32 Bad Faith

Trap is likely the only literature that will capture the structure of feeling of the period in which it was produced.

Issue 32 Bad Faith
Sick Puppy
Issue 32 Bad Faith

Smolensk is part of the heavy mythology of the borderlands.

Issue 32 Bad Faith
Homecomings
Issue 32 Bad Faith
Three Stories
Issue 32 Bad Faith

Just kidding. It’s not even art. I’m a scab!

Issue 32 Bad Faith
Corruptions and Duplicates of Form
Issue 32 Bad Faith

In the history of economic thought, “the long run” has been a bludgeon to wield in a policy fight.

Issue 32 Bad Faith
Ghost World
Issue 32 Bad Faith

More by this Author

October 6, 2016
Every Body Goes Haywire