On Privilege

Privilege discourse offers a way for members of the same class to discuss differences in the same room.

Class is back in American discourse. It has become impossible to deny—and strange that it was ever possible to deny—that your inheritance, income, and credentials guarantee certain advantages, and that these advantages might have been wrested from those less fortunate. Ever since the Occupy movement so pithily pointed out the distance between the top earners and the rest, the inequalities of American life have been apparent to anyone with a flicker of sentience.

But the concept of class returns after a long period of retreat and transformation. For decades, class-based forms of critique were replaced by forms whose sources were not entirely or even primarily economic. For a time, the importance of social class as fundamental to explaining power imbalances—something taken for granted for generations—faded into the background.

The reasons why this happened are still obscure enough to be worth rehearsing. By the mid-1970s, in the wealthy Western countries, labor organizing had been successful enough to guarantee “middle-class” incomes to an enormous group of workers. Even unorganized workers reaped benefits. At the same time, the proportion of white-collar workers—professionals, clerks in offices, academics—came to exceed that of blue-collar workers. No matter how low their income, they tended to identify as middle class, and why not? Their work was clean, done amid bright lighting and powerful air-conditioning, and though they might be bossed around, they could at least dream of becoming the bosses themselves. Blue-collar workers, meanwhile, often earned more than their white-collar peers, and so potentially belonged to the middle, too.

More from Issue 20

Issue 20 Survival

If this was not yet a movement, it was definitely a mood—antifree—and it was fighting a more difficult battle.

Issue 20 Survival
Dire Straits
Issue 20 Survival

We kissed, but my whatever had not healed. It was hot and dry. (I mean my brain.)

Issue 20 Survival

Every cheap shot, each subtle disrespect, any advantage unfairly taken—these have to be balanced out.

Issue 20 Survival

“You know what?” Val said. “Screw those guys. I am going to ride by in a Mercedes-Benz.”

Issue 20 Survival

Caren winces. “You have another six weeks to come up with a summer jam.”

Issue 20 Survival
Color Theory
Issue 20 Survival

That was the moment I should have realized that the narco business is no joke.

Issue 20 Survival
Nobody's Protest Novel
Issue 20 Survival

At the same time, there has been an obvious change of mood.

Issue 20 Survival

Women’s bathrooms need to be bigger, or something.

More by this Author

September 8, 2006

Part of Mahfouz’s achievement is its sheer extent, its superabundant precision.

Issue 7 Correction

The injunction had once been to marry Jews. Now it is merely to masturbate to them.

Issue 1 Negation

There is a kind of fake refinement that turns into a vulgarity . . . it comes from deciding what other people can’t say.

July 18, 2011

Thoreau early in life taught school with his brother, but otherwise returned to Harvard only for its library.

Issue 13 Machine Politics

One started a chant about love transcending all. We repeated it, trailing off with groans when the meaning sank in.

October 20, 2014
N1BReading, Part 2